THE MOTOR ATLAS GUIDE

Why Crash-Test Ratings Vary by Model Year

Never assume two model years share the same crash rating or test criteria; verify year, model variant, the program's method and whether a rating was carried over.

Model-year calendar and vehicle safety testing

Understand how vehicle redesigns, carried-over test results, different testing protocols and trim-specific safety equipment affect NHTSA and IIHS crash ratings across model years.

Quick answer: Never assume two model years share the same crash rating or test criteria; verify year, model variant, the program's method and whether a rating was carried over.

Why can a car’s safety rating change from one year to the next?

A vehicle’s crash-test rating may change because its design changed, the testing organization updated its criteria, the available safety equipment changed, or the earlier rating does not apply to the newer version. A newer model is not automatically safer, and an unchanged number of stars does not prove unchanged protection.

Safety testing is both vehicle-specific and program-specific.

NHTSA’s US 5-Star Safety Ratings and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) use different tests and grading systems.

Ratings are not interchangeable and should not be described as a single universal score.

The four reasons ratings can differ

Source of change What may have happened What buyers should verify
Vehicle redesign Structure, airbags, restraints or weight changed Whether the rated model matches your year/configuration
New test protocol Organization added or strengthened a scenario Year and test criteria behind the result
Equipment or trim change Headlights or crash-avoidance systems differ Which tested or rated equipment is installed
Rating carried over Organization determined older testing still applies Extension notes and the relevant vehicle variants

IIHS explains that it does not retest every model each year. It can carry forward results when changes do not materially affect relevant performance; that is not equivalent to saying the newest model was freshly crashed. Read the exact IIHS rating description.

Compare NHTSA ratings correctly

NHTSA reports crash protection and rollover results within its 5-Star system.

Its official guidance limits frontal crash comparisons to vehicles of the same class and with curb weights within the agency’s specified range.

Side crash and rollover rating comparisons have different applicability.

Do not imply that one overall star number proves a smaller car will protect occupants identically in all collisions with much heavier vehicles.

Search the official NHTSA rating tool by model year, make and model. Where offered, select the exact body style, drivetrain or other tested variant. A missing rating does not mean the model failed; it may not have been selected or completed for that program.

Compare IIHS ratings correctly

IIHS assesses specific crashworthiness and crash-avoidance aspects.

Criteria, headlights, pedestrian detection and trim availability may vary. A past Top Safety Pick award is not necessarily equivalent to a current award because the requirements can change.

Check the actual awarded model year and award criteria rather than treating the badge as permanent.

The bar can rise from one year to the next. For 2025, a Good moderate overlap rating was needed only for the higher award. For 2026, IIHS requires Good in that test for either award, as its 2026 award announcement explains.

IIHS lists some models by year range, such as 2026-27. It lists others by single year. In its 2026 award list, the 2026 Hyundai Ioniq 5 appears as a Top Safety Pick+ and the 2027 model as a Top Safety Pick. That list can change, so check the current page.

A carried-over IIHS crashworthiness result can coexist with a changed headlight or front crash-prevention rating.

Read both the test detail and applicable variants.

What NHTSA added for model year 2027

NHTSA picks the vehicles it will test for each model year. Its October 15, 2026 list for model year 2027 names 23 vehicles for frontal, side and rollover tests.

NHTSA also announced a new pedestrian protection assessment for model year 2027. It measures injury risk to the head, hips, legs and knees.

A yellow box on the ratings page shows pass, fail, pending or not submitted. Its model year 2027 testing list also covers driver assistance checks. These include automatic emergency braking, lane keeping assist and blind spot warning.

An older model year may not show these newer results.

How IIHS tests have changed over the years

IIHS says its test lineup has changed as it challenges automakers to improve. It updated the side test in 2021 with a more severe crash. It updated the moderate overlap front test in 2022 to include back seat protection.

Some tests were discontinued, including the original side test and roof strength. IIHS still shows those old results for older models.

An older IIHS rating can therefore come from a test that no longer exists in its original form. Read the IIHS test descriptions before comparing years.

A model-year comparison checklist

  1. Write down the exact year, make, model, body style, drivetrain and trim of both choices.
  2. Search both vehicles independently in the NHTSA ratings database.
  3. Search both vehicles in IIHS and read whether each result was tested or extended.
  4. Look for redesigns, changes to airbags or structure, and newly standard safety features.
  5. Check headlight and crash-prevention ratings for the equipment on the vehicle for sale.
  6. Run a VIN-based open recall check in addition to reviewing historical crash ratings.
  7. If results are missing or different, read program notes rather than inferring a safety ranking.

The NHTSA versus IIHS comparison guide helps explain what each testing organization actually measures.

Frequently asked questions

Does every new model year get a new crash test?

No. IIHS may extend prior ratings after assessing changes; NHTSA selects vehicles for testing. Check the actual record for that year.

Does a five-star vehicle stay five-star forever?

Not as a statement about every future version or all test methods. Verify the exact year and applicable NHTSA assessment.

Does a missing IIHS award mean a vehicle is unsafe?

Not necessarily. Awards have particular eligibility rules and criteria. Consult individual test ratings and equipment, not only a missing award badge.

How this guide was prepared: Researched explanatory guidance using the sources linked on this page. We have not road-tested a vehicle or completed a hands-on inspection for this article. The displayed byline is a fictional editorial persona, not a real individual author or certified technician reviewer. Motor Atlas is responsible for this content. Confirm vehicle-specific procedures with the manufacturer, and ask an appropriate professional before safety-critical repairs, legal filings or financial decisions.

Related reading