THE MOTOR ATLAS GUIDE

IIHS Top Safety Pick Ratings Explained

A 2026 IIHS award signals results under that year's criteria—not a guarantee for every trim, build date, collision or future model year.

Vehicle crash safety award and test shield

Learn the difference between 2026 IIHS Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+, what tests and standard safety equipment qualify, and how to interpret model-year and build-date restrictions.

Quick answer: A 2026 IIHS award signals results under that year's criteria—not a guarantee for every trim, build date, collision or future model year.

What does IIHS Top Safety Pick mean in 2026?

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) gives Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+ awards to vehicles meeting defined crashworthiness, headlight and crash-avoidance thresholds for a particular award year. The “+” designation is more demanding in specified crash-prevention evaluations; neither award makes an owner immune to injury.

An award is not the same as NHTSA’s five-star rating, and it does not apply indefinitely to every vehicle bearing the same model name.

Always identify the model year, body style and any qualifying build-date restrictions.

2026 Top Safety Pick vs Top Safety Pick+

2026 IIHS requirement Top Safety Pick Top Safety Pick+
Small overlap front Good Good
Updated moderate overlap front Good Good
Side crashworthiness Good Good
Headlights across trims Acceptable or Good Acceptable or Good
Pedestrian front crash prevention Acceptable or Good, qualifying system standard Good, qualifying system standard
Updated vehicle-to-vehicle front crash prevention 2.0 Not an additional base-award requirement Acceptable or Good, qualifying system standard

These are the program’s 2026 award thresholds, as reported on the official IIHS award page. The program may change its criteria in future years, and tested systems must meet IIHS standard-equipment rules for the award. Do not assume the same table defines a 2025 or 2027 award.

What do the crash tests represent?

IIHS evaluates scenarios including small front overlap, moderate front overlap and side impact. The organization also rates headlights and selected automatic emergency braking systems. Its test methodology page explains equipment, ratings and how some results may be carried forward when engineering is unchanged.

For 2026, both award tiers require a Good rating in the updated moderate-overlap front test, which emphasizes rear-seat occupant protection as well as people in front. IIHS also increased demands for the higher award tier on pedestrian and vehicle-to-vehicle crash prevention. Read the 2026 announcement for the exact changes.

What the side and back seat tests involve

In the side test, a 4,200-pound rig hits the driver side at 37 mph. IIHS made the test more severe in 2021. Dummies the size of a small woman or 12-year-old child sit in the driver seat and in the second row.

The updated moderate overlap test also places a smaller dummy in the second seat behind the driver. A belt-tension sensor and a pressure mat on its chest add data on back seat chest injury risk.

The small overlap test is run twice, once on the driver side and once on the passenger side.

How the vehicle-to-vehicle test works

The vehicle-to-vehicle front crash prevention 2.0 evaluation began in 2024. It includes runs at 31, 37 and 43 mph. It uses a passenger car target, a motorcycle target and a semitrailer.

The earlier version was discontinued in 2022. It looked at lower-speed rear-end crashes with a passenger car target only.

In 2026, this test counts only toward Top Safety Pick+. Qualifying front crash prevention must be standard equipment for either award.

Who runs the tests behind an award

IIHS cannot test every model every year. It can accept some manufacturer test data under its eligibility policy.

It does not accept manufacturer tests for headlight ratings or for the updated moderate overlap test. It also runs occasional audit tests to check manufacturer results.

Why the build date and trim can matter

Sometimes an award applies only to vehicles manufactured after a specified month, due to a running safety-equipment or lighting improvement.

The award listing may also distinguish sedan versus hatchback, hybrid versus gasoline or other versions.

The manufacture date is normally shown on a label in the vehicle door jamb.

Cross-check that date, model year and the relevant IIHS record. A dealership listing that simply says “Top Safety Pick+” can be incomplete if the actual VIN or body style falls outside the award’s applicability.

Does the award identify the safest car in America?

No.

IIHS awards identify vehicles meeting the tested requirements, often within size categories.

IIHS cautions that larger, heavier vehicles can generally offer advantages in some real-world collisions with smaller cars, even when both earn awards.

Crashworthiness also depends on how a specific crash occurs.

The absence of an award does not necessarily mean a model failed every safety test; the vehicle may not have been evaluated sufficiently to qualify or may have missed one particular award threshold.

Study individual test results rather than only a badge.

How to use the award when buying a car

  1. Search the official 2026 IIHS award list, filtering to the exact model.
  2. Read every model-year, body-style and build-date condition.
  3. Open the detailed ratings and see which tests were performed or carried forward.
  4. Check headlight versions and the standard automatic emergency braking system.
  5. Compare with official NHTSA tests for the same model year—different tests, not interchangeable scores.
  6. Run a separate VIN-based open recall check before buying a used car.
  7. Test seating, child seats and visibility in the actual vehicle; crash results do not replace practical fit.

See our NHTSA vs IIHS comparison and VIN recall guide for the other checks.

Frequently asked questions

Is Top Safety Pick+ always safer than Top Safety Pick?

It meets stricter specified criteria for the award year, but a badge alone does not predict every real-world collision outcome.

Are Top Safety Pick and NHTSA five stars equivalent?

No. They are independent programs with different protocols and scales.

Does a 2026 award automatically apply to a 2027 vehicle?

No. Confirm the model year and exact applicable award entry. Tests and eligibility may change.

How this guide was prepared: Researched explanatory guidance using the sources linked on this page. We have not road-tested a vehicle or completed a hands-on inspection for this article. The displayed byline is a fictional editorial persona, not a real individual author or certified technician reviewer. Motor Atlas is responsible for this content. Confirm vehicle-specific procedures with the manufacturer, and ask an appropriate professional before safety-critical repairs, legal filings or financial decisions.

Related reading