THE MOTOR ATLAS GUIDE

NHTSA vs IIHS Crash Testing: Key Differences

Check both NHTSA and IIHS for the exact model year and variant. Their tests, scoring systems and award criteria are different; neither replaces a recall or equipment check.

Two independent vehicle crash-test rating systems

Understand how NHTSA's US five-star government ratings differ from IIHS crashworthiness and crash-avoidance ratings, and how to compare specific vehicle years.

Quick answer: Check both NHTSA and IIHS for the exact model year and variant. Their tests, scoring systems and award criteria are different; neither replaces a recall or equipment check.

The short answer: they measure different things

NHTSA is the US government agency behind the Five-Star Safety Ratings program. IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety) is an independent, insurance-industry-supported nonprofit that publishes crashworthiness and crash-avoidance ratings as well as TOP SAFETY PICK awards.

Both can inform a purchase, but a five-star NHTSA score does not equal an IIHS ‘Good’ result, and one agency’s missing score cannot be filled in from the other.

What each rating system covers

Feature NHTSA IIHS
Organization Federal agency Independent insurance-industry-supported nonprofit
Main ratings language One to five stars, including overall score where available Good, Acceptable, Marginal, Poor for many tests; additional system-specific scales
Crashworthiness Frontal and side impact Small overlap, moderate overlap, side and other protocol-specific tests
Rollover Dedicated rollover-resistance rating Not the same government rollover star rating
Crash avoidance Safety technology assessments within its evolving program Pedestrian/vehicle front-crash prevention, headlights and other evaluations
Awards NHTSA star scores TOP SAFETY PICK / TOP SAFETY PICK+ with model-year-specific requirements

Tests change over time.

For example, IIHS updated several frontal and side test protocols and tightened 2026 award requirements.

When reading an older article, confirm whether it uses the protocol and award criteria that apply to the vehicle/model year under consideration.

How each program sets up its crash tests

NHTSA’s frontal test crashes a vehicle into a fixed barrier at 35 mph. An average-size male dummy sits in the driver seat. A small female dummy sits in the front passenger seat.

NHTSA’s side barrier test hits a standing vehicle with a 3,015-pound moving barrier at 38.5 mph. Its side pole test pulls a vehicle sideways at 20 mph into a 25 cm pole.

IIHS uses different crashes. Its small overlap test drives a vehicle into a rigid barrier at 40 mph. Only 25% of the front overlaps the barrier. Its moderate overlap test also runs at 40 mph, with 40% overlap.

IIHS says ratings in both frontal tests can only be compared among vehicles of similar weight. NHTSA’s ratings page describes the NHTSA tests, and the IIHS small overlap and moderate overlap pages describe IIHS’s.

How NHTSA works out its Overall Vehicle Score

The Overall Vehicle Score combines injury probabilities from the frontal and side tests. It adds a projected injury risk based on rollover resistance.

NHTSA weights each part to reflect how often that crash type causes real-world injuries. It then compares the result with the average injury risk across the vehicle fleet.

Five stars means overall injury risk is much less than average. One star means it is much greater than average.

A safety concern symbol may also appear on a ratings label. NHTSA says these concerns, such as a fuel leak or a door opening, are not part of the Overall Vehicle Score.

Important NHTSA comparison limitation

NHTSA specifically cautions that frontal crash and Overall Vehicle Score ratings should only be compared for vehicles in the same class and within 250 pounds of curb weight.

Those ratings represent particular standardized collision conditions.

Its side crash and rollover ratings can be compared across classes under NHTSA’s stated test methodology.

That means comparing a compact sedan’s overall stars directly with a heavy SUV’s overall stars may be misleading.

Read NHTSA’s methodology before ranking vehicles based on a single number.

For the core government program see NHTSA Five-Star ratings.

What ‘not rated’ really means

Neither organization can test every configuration and every model year. Not rated indicates absent published results for a particular assessment; it does not automatically indicate that the vehicle failed or lacks legally required safety equipment.

NHTSA notes that vehicles sold in the US must be certified by manufacturers as meeting applicable federal safety standards even if not tested in the voluntary consumer-rating program.

A model’s rating can also vary by production date, body type, headlights, drivetrain or equipped systems.

IIHS sometimes extends ratings from one model year or related version after checking whether relevant vehicle structures and protection systems changed.

Verify notes about tested variants and build dates rather than relying on a simplified dealer badge.

How to compare two cars responsibly

  1. Record the precise make, model, body style, model year and trim/variant for both.
  2. Look up each on NHTSA and IIHS.
  3. Read individual test categories, not only the overall star count or award logo.
  4. Check when each test protocol and award criterion applied.
  5. Review standard versus optional ADAS and headlight equipment on the exact trim.
  6. Search open safety recalls using the VIN when available.
  7. Include your own needs: rear-seat protection, child-seat compatibility, visibility and vehicle size.

Safety is more than crash ratings: driver behavior, tires, maintenance and the situation of an actual crash matter.

No consumer test score guarantees injury prevention.

Frequently asked questions

Is an IIHS TOP SAFETY PICK+ vehicle always safer than a five-star NHTSA vehicle?

That comparison is not valid by itself. Awards and stars use different tests and eligibility rules. Compare the same model-year vehicles’ individual results and safety equipment.

Why can the same model have different IIHS results in different years?

Vehicles change, tests evolve, and evaluation or award criteria change. Review the exact year and qualification notes.

Does a high crash-test rating mean the car has no recalls?

No. Recalls address specific defects and can occur on highly rated cars. Check the actual VIN separately.

How this guide was prepared: Researched explanatory guidance using the sources linked on this page. We have not road-tested a vehicle or completed a hands-on inspection for this article. The displayed byline is a fictional editorial persona, not a real individual author or certified technician reviewer. Motor Atlas is responsible for this content. Confirm vehicle-specific procedures with the manufacturer, and ask an appropriate professional before safety-critical repairs, legal filings or financial decisions.

Related reading