THE MOTOR ATLAS GUIDE

All-Terrain vs Highway Terrain Tires

All-terrain is a compromise tire, so match your real mix of pavement and trail to the manual's size and load rules before paying for extra off-road grip.

Chunky off-road tread blocks on dirt split from smooth ribbed tread blocks on asphalt along a diagonal divider

Compare all-terrain and highway-terrain tires using NHTSA guidance, fueleconomy.gov rolling resistance data and a truck owner's manual on size and towing.

Quick answer: All-terrain is a compromise tire, so match your real mix of pavement and trail to the manual's size and load rules before paying for extra off-road grip.

All-terrain vs highway-terrain tires: a compromise against a road-first choice

An all-terrain tire is built as a compromise between road driving and off-road grip, while a highway-terrain tire is the road-first choice, and neither name is a federal grade. NHTSA’s tire guidance says all-terrain tires are mainly used on four-wheel-drive vehicles. It calls them a good compromise between on-road driving and off-road capability.

NHTSA does not list “highway-terrain” as a type, and no source read for this guide defines it. Treat it as a product-line name and read the specification page for the exact tire. If you want a wider look at categories, see our touring vs performance tires guide. The hub is Tires, Wheels and Brakes.

What tread design changes

NHTSA’s engineering reference, The Pneumatic Tire, lists the features designers adjust. They include the number of ribs, groove spacing, percent void, shoulder slots and sipes. The reference says these choices can affect traction, handling and water exit paths. It adds that the number of pitches and their sequence, meaning the varying lengths of the tread elements, can affect traction, noise and wear.

The same reference says a tread pattern is designed to give uniform wear, channel water out of the footprint and keep pattern noise down on many road surfaces. It also says the tread compound balances wear, traction, handling and rolling resistance. The pages read do not rank all-terrain against highway-terrain designs, so any claim that one is quieter needs the tire maker’s own data.

Fuel economy and rolling resistance

FuelEconomy.gov explains that rolling resistance comes from the deformation of a tire as it rolls. For cars, it says a 5 to 7 percent cut in rolling resistance raises fuel efficiency by 1 percent. It adds that such gains must be balanced against traction, durability and noise.

The pages read give no figure for all-terrain tires, so none is quoted here. FuelEconomy.gov does say that improperly aligned or inflated tires lower fuel economy by raising rolling resistance. It also notes that four-wheel drive reduces fuel economy because engaging all four wheels makes the engine work harder.

Side-by-side checklist

The table sorts the questions that matter. It shows what the sources say, not a verdict on either tire.

Question What the sources say
Is the name an official class? NHTSA lists all-terrain but not highway-terrain
Snow rating Look for the three-peak mountain snowflake on the sidewall
Fuel economy No all-terrain figure found; rolling resistance trades off against traction and noise
Size and load Ram’s manual allows only sizes and load ratings approved for the vehicle
Towing Ram’s manual limits spare-tire towing and asks for trailer tire checks

Size, load and snow rules from the manual

The 2025 Ram 2500/3500 owner’s manual warns against any tire, wheel size, load rating or speed rating other than the one specified. It says replacement tires must equal the load capacity of the original size. It warns that a different size may cause false speedometer and odometer readings. It also recommends replacing the two front or two rear tires as a pair.

For snow, the manual says snow tires carry a mountain and snowflake symbol. Transport Canada’s winter tire note says the symbol means a tire passed a snow traction test. Do not assume an all-terrain tire carries it. Read the sidewall.

Towing and off-road cautions

The Ram manual says not to tow a trailer on a compact spare. It says not to exceed 50 mph when towing on a full-size spare. It also asks drivers to check trailer tires for proper pressure and wear before towing.

For rough ground, the same manual describes airing down for off-road use. It says lower pressure can improve traction and ride, and that different terrain, tires and vehicles need different pressures. It says to return tires to normal pressure before driving on the road. It warns that reduced pressure raises the risk of tire damage and tire unseating.

The manual names 15 psi as the lowest pressure to use in soft sand on that truck. That figure belongs to that vehicle, not to every tire. Our guide to approaching steep off-road hills covers technique, and our towing capacity vs payload guide covers load limits.

Frequently asked questions

Do all-terrain tires hurt fuel economy?

The sources read give no all-terrain figure. FuelEconomy.gov says rolling resistance affects fuel efficiency and must be balanced against traction, durability and noise. Compare the maker’s data for a specific tire, and keep it inflated to the door label pressure.

Can I put all-terrain tires on a car that is not four-wheel drive?

NHTSA says all-terrain tires are mainly used on four-wheel-drive vehicles, but its page does not say more about other vehicles. Your owner’s manual decides which sizes and load ratings are approved. A tire shop can confirm a match for your vehicle.

Are all-terrain tires good in snow?

NHTSA says winter tires are more effective in deep snow than all-season tires. For snow traction, check the sidewall for the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol. The all-terrain name alone does not show it.

Should I lower tire pressure off-road?

The Ram manual says lower pressure can improve traction, but it also raises the risk of tire damage and unseating. It says to return to normal pressure before driving on the road. Follow your own manual and carry a way to air the tires back up.

How this guide was prepared: Researched explanatory guidance using the sources linked on this page. We have not road-tested a vehicle or completed a hands-on inspection for this article. The displayed byline is a fictional editorial persona, not a real individual author or certified technician reviewer. Motor Atlas is responsible for this content. Confirm vehicle-specific procedures with the manufacturer, and ask an appropriate professional before safety-critical repairs, legal filings or financial decisions.

Related reading