THE MOTOR ATLAS GUIDE

How to Choose a Reputable Auto Repair Shop

Pick a shop before a breakdown, check licenses and complaint records, ask to see current credentials and get warranty terms in writing.

An auto repair shop front with two service bays, a certification rosette, a five-star rating sign and a magnifying glass checking the shop.

Use FTC and ASE guidance to vet a repair shop before you need one: recommendations, licenses, complaint records, technician credentials and warranty terms.

Quick answer: Pick a shop before a breakdown, check licenses and complaint records, ask to see current credentials and get warranty terms in writing.

Pick a shop before you need one

The best time to choose a repair shop is before a breakdown: gather recommendations, check licenses and complaint records, look at technician credentials and compare repair warranties. The FTC says to look for a shop before you need one, so you are not rushed into a last-minute decision. Its auto repair guidance is the main source for this guide.

This guide is about picking the shop. Once you have a shop and a diagnosis, use what to ask a mechanic before approving repairs and how to compare auto repair estimates. The DIY Car Repair hub has more repair topics.

The FTC suggests three starting steps:

  • Ask friends, family and other people you trust for recommendations.
  • Shop around by phone and online for the best deal.
  • Compare warranty policies on repairs.

Check licenses and complaint records

The FTC says to ask to see current licenses if state or local law requires repair shops to be licensed or registered. Requirements differ by state, so a missing license is a question to ask, not proof of a problem.

The FTC also says your state attorney general’s office or local consumer protection agency may know whether there is a record of complaints about a particular shop. A quick call or search before you hand over keys can save trouble later.

Ask one more thing at this stage. The FTC says to make sure the shop will honor your vehicle’s warranty. Our guide to what a factory warranty covers explains the basics.

What ASE certification does and does not tell you

Many shops display an Automotive Service Excellence seal. The FTC says certification indicates that some or all of the technicians meet basic standards of knowledge and competence in specific technical areas. It says to make sure the certifications are current. It also says certification alone is no guarantee of good or honest work.

ASE describes its own program on its drivers page:

  • Technicians need a minimum of 2 years of qualified work experience and must pass a test for each certification.
  • Certified technicians must retest every 5 years to keep their certifications.
  • ASE certifies technicians, not businesses. It suggests asking your service professional to see their credentials.

ASE also runs a Blue Seal program. It says that over 600 shops across the country have a large percentage of ASE-certified technicians. You can search for them with the Blue Seal locator. A shop outside the program can still be a good one, so treat the locator as one input.

The FTC adds that you should ask whether the technician or shop has experience with your make and model.

A screening checklist for a new shop

Use the table before the first visit. The “Source” column shows where each item comes from.

Check What to ask or do Source
Recommendations Ask people you trust who they use FTC
License or registration Ask to see current ones, where state or local law requires them FTC
Complaint record Ask your state attorney general or local consumer protection agency FTC
Technician credentials Ask to see current certifications, such as ASE FTC, ASE
Make and model experience Ask if they work on your type of vehicle FTC
Warranty Ask for the repair warranty in writing and ask if your vehicle warranty will be honored FTC

Watch how a shop handles maintenance advice

The FTC says some shops create their own maintenance schedules, calling for more frequent service than the manufacturer recommends. It advises you to compare a shop’s schedule with the one in your owner’s manual. If a shop recommends service beyond the manual, ask it to explain why.

For expensive or complicated repairs, the FTC says to consider a second opinion. It adds that shops doing only diagnostic work may give an objective opinion about which repairs are necessary. It says to find out whether there is a diagnostic charge if you take the work elsewhere.

On warranties, the FTC says there is no “standard warranty” on repairs. Get what the shop promises in writing.

If a shop lets you down

The FTC advises you to document everything: dates, times, expenses and the names of people you dealt with. Talk to the shop manager or owner first.

If that does not work, contact your attorney general or local consumer protection agency. The FTC says another option is a small claims court, where you do not need an attorney.

Before you escalate, check the work itself with how to verify that a repair was completed.

Frequently asked questions

Is an ASE-certified shop automatically a good shop?

No. The FTC says certification is no guarantee of good or honest work. ASE says it certifies technicians, not businesses. Use certification alongside recommendations, complaint records and warranty terms.

Where can I check complaints about a repair shop?

The FTC says your state attorney general’s office or local consumer protection agency may know whether there is a record of complaints. Ask for the shop by its exact name and location.

Should I choose a dealer or an independent shop?

The sources used here do not rank one over the other. The FTC says to make sure the shop will honor your vehicle’s warranty and to ask about experience with your make and model. Judge each shop on those points.

Should I pay a shop for a safety recall repair?

Check first. NHTSA says it monitors each safety recall so that owners receive safe, free and effective remedies from manufacturers. Look up your vehicle on NHTSA’s recall page and contact the manufacturer or dealer before paying anyone.

How this guide was prepared: Researched explanatory guidance using the sources linked on this page. We have not road-tested a vehicle or completed a hands-on inspection for this article. The displayed byline is a fictional editorial persona, not a real individual author or certified technician reviewer. Motor Atlas is responsible for this content. Confirm vehicle-specific procedures with the manufacturer, and ask an appropriate professional before safety-critical repairs, legal filings or financial decisions.

Related reading